What Should I Do If the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Contacts Me?

A Guide by Avard Law Offices, Cape Coral, Florida

If you’ve been involved in a car accident that wasn’t your fault, it’s not uncommon for the other driver’s insurance company to reach out to you. While this might seem like a straightforward part of the process, it’s crucial to handle these interactions with caution. At Avard Law Offices in Cape Coral, Florida, we frequently advise clients on the best ways to deal with such situations.

1. Understand Their Motive

First and foremost, understand that the insurance adjuster’s primary role is to minimize the company’s payout. Their friendly demeanor is part of a strategy to gather information that could potentially be used to devalue or deny your claim.

2. Be Cautious With Your Words

When you speak with the other party’s insurance company, be very cautious about what you say. Even seemingly innocuous statements can be misconstrued or taken out of context to imply that you bear some responsibility for the accident.

3. Do Not Provide a Recorded Statement

It’s a common practice for insurance adjusters to ask for a recorded statement. Politely decline this request. These recordings can be used to pin you down on details that might not be fully clear immediately after the accident. It’s crucial to consult with your attorney before providing any such statement.

4. Avoid Discussing Injuries

Immediately after an accident, the full extent of your injuries may not be apparent. Discussing your physical condition with the insurance company can lead to complications later if additional injuries or complications arise.

5. Do Not Accept a Quick Settlement

Insurance companies often offer a quick settlement to close the case swiftly and economically. These initial offers are usually much lower than what you might be entitled to. Accepting such an offer without legal consultation can significantly undermine your compensation.

6. Direct Them to Your Attorney

The best course of action when contacted by the other party’s insurance company is to direct them to your attorney. At Avard Law Offices, we handle all communications with the insurance companies to ensure your rights are protected and to prevent any statements that could harm your claim.

7. Consult Your Attorney Before Signing Anything

Before signing any documents from the insurance company, including releases or settlements, consult with your attorney. These documents can have far-reaching implications on your ability to seek further compensation.

8. Keep Records of All Communications

Maintain a record of all communications with the insurance company, including dates, times, and a brief summary of the conversation. This information can be invaluable to your attorney in handling your case.

9. Be Aware of Time Limits

While it’s important to be cautious, also be aware of any time limits for filing claims. Your attorney can advise you on these deadlines and ensure that all necessary steps are taken in a timely manner.

10. Focus on Your Recovery

Your primary focus should be on your recovery. Let your attorney handle the legal aspects, including negotiations with the insurance company. This allows you to concentrate on getting back to full health.


Dealing with the other driver’s insurance company can be a tricky part of navigating post-accident procedures. Remember, you don’t have to face this alone. At Avard Law Offices, we have the expertise and experience to guide you through each step, ensuring that your rights are protected and you receive the compensation you deserve.

Navigating the aftermath of a car accident can be overwhelming, but with the right legal support, you can move forward confidently. If you find yourself in such a situation, don’t hesitate to reach out to Avard Law Offices in Cape Coral, Florida, for expert legal advice and representation.


Fill out my online form.