How to Gather Evidence for a VA Disability Claim

Understanding the Importance of Evidence in VA Disability Claims

When filing a VA disability claim, evidence is the cornerstone of a successful application. The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) requires proof to establish a service connection for the claimed disability and to assess its severity. Without sufficient evidence, even legitimate claims can face delays or denials. Evidence serves as the foundation for demonstrating how a veteran’s condition is linked to their military service and how it impacts their daily life. It also helps the VA assign an appropriate disability rating, which determines the level of benefits a veteran will receive. By understanding the importance of evidence and gathering it effectively, veterans can significantly improve their chances of securing the benefits they deserve.

Types of Evidence Needed for a VA Disability Claim

To build a strong VA disability claim, veterans need to provide various types of evidence that collectively support their case. These include medical records, service records, lay statements, and expert opinions. Each category plays a unique role in substantiating the claim and ensuring the VA has a complete picture of the veteran’s situation.

Medical Records

Medical records are among the most critical pieces of evidence in a VA disability claim. These documents provide a detailed account of the veteran’s diagnosis, treatment history, and ongoing care related to the disability. For example, if a veteran is claiming benefits for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), their medical records should include a formal diagnosis from a qualified mental health professional, notes from therapy sessions, and any prescribed medications. Medical records not only confirm the existence of the condition but also demonstrate its severity and impact on the veteran’s life. Veterans should ensure their medical records are up-to-date and include all relevant information to avoid gaps in their claim.

Service Records

Service records are essential for establishing a connection between the disability and military service. These documents can include deployment history, incident reports, performance evaluations, and discharge papers. For instance, if a veteran sustained a back injury during a training exercise, their service records might contain an incident report detailing the event. These records help the VA verify that the disability occurred or was aggravated during military service, which is a key requirement for approval. Veterans should review their service records carefully to identify any documentation that supports their claim.

Lay Statements

Lay statements provide a personal perspective on the veteran’s condition and its impact on their daily life. These statements can come from the veteran, family members, or fellow service members who witnessed the events leading to the disability. For example, a veteran might write a statement describing how their knee injury limits their ability to perform basic tasks, while a spouse might detail how the injury has affected the veteran’s mood and mobility. Lay statements add a human element to the claim and can be particularly valuable when medical or service records are incomplete.

Expert Opinions

Expert opinions from independent medical professionals or vocational experts can strengthen a VA disability claim. These opinions provide an objective analysis of the veteran’s condition and its implications. For example, a vocational expert might assess how a veteran’s disability affects their ability to work, while a medical specialist could provide a detailed evaluation of the condition’s progression. Expert opinions are especially useful in complex cases where additional evidence is needed to clarify the severity or service connection of the disability.

How to Obtain Service Records and Medical Documentation

Gathering the necessary documentation for a VA disability claim can be a daunting task, but there are clear steps veterans can follow to access their records efficiently.

Requesting Records from the National Archives

The National Archives is a valuable resource for obtaining service records. Veterans can submit a request online through the National Archives website or complete Standard Form 180 (SF-180) and mail it to the appropriate address. It’s important to provide as much detail as possible, including the veteran’s full name, branch of service, and dates of service, to expedite the process. If records are missing or incomplete, veterans can request a reconstruction of their file using alternative sources, such as unit histories or morning reports.

Accessing Medical Records from VA Facilities

Veterans who have received treatment at VA hospitals or clinics can request their medical records directly from the VA. This can be done online through the VA’s My HealtheVet portal or by submitting VA Form 10-5345 to the facility where they received care. The VA is required to provide these records upon request, but veterans should allow sufficient time for processing. Ensuring these records are complete and accurate is crucial for building a strong claim.

Gathering Private Medical Records

For veterans who have received care from private healthcare providers, obtaining medical records may require additional steps. Veterans should contact their providers directly and complete authorization forms to release the records. It’s important to specify the type of information needed, such as diagnostic reports or treatment summaries, to avoid delays. Veterans should also follow up with providers to ensure the records are sent promptly.

Tips for Writing Effective Lay Statements

Lay statements can be a powerful tool in a VA disability claim, but they must be well-crafted to make an impact.

Structuring Your Statement

A strong lay statement should be organized and detailed. Begin by introducing yourself and your relationship to the veteran, if applicable. Then, describe the disability and its effects on the veteran’s daily life, using specific examples and chronological details. For instance, a veteran might explain how their back injury prevents them from lifting heavy objects or sitting for extended periods. The statement should be clear, concise, and focused on the facts.

Avoiding Common Mistakes

When writing lay statements, avoid vague language or unsupported claims. Statements should be specific and backed by evidence whenever possible. For example, instead of saying, “The injury affects my work,” a veteran could write, “Due to my knee injury, I can no longer stand for more than 15 minutes, which has forced me to leave my job as a cashier.” Avoid exaggerating the severity of the condition, as this can undermine credibility.

Leveraging Buddy Statements for Additional Support

Buddy statements from fellow service members can provide valuable corroboration for a VA disability claim.

Who Can Provide Buddy Statements?

Buddy statements can be written by anyone who served with the veteran and witnessed the events leading to the disability. This could include unit members, commanding officers, or even civilian contractors who were present during the incident. These statements help verify the veteran’s account and provide additional context.

How to Format and Submit Buddy Statements

Buddy statements should be formatted similarly to lay statements, with a clear introduction, detailed account of the events, and a signature. Veterans should ensure the statements are signed and dated before submitting them to the VA. Including contact information for the writer can also be helpful in case the VA needs to verify the statement.

Using Independent Medical Opinions to Strengthen Your Claim

Independent medical opinions can add credibility and detail to a VA disability claim.

Finding Qualified Experts

Veterans should seek out medical professionals who specialize in VA disability evaluations. These experts are familiar with VA requirements and can provide thorough assessments. Online directories and veteran organizations can help locate qualified professionals.

What to Include in an Independent Medical Opinion

A strong medical opinion should include a detailed analysis of the veteran’s condition, references to medical literature, and an explanation of how the disability is connected to military service. The opinion should be clear, concise, and supported by evidence.

Organizing and Submitting Your Evidence to the VA

Proper organization and submission of evidence are crucial for avoiding delays or denials.

Creating a Comprehensive Evidence Packet

Veterans should compile all documents into a logical order, starting with a cover letter summarizing the evidence. Each piece of evidence should be labeled and organized to make it easy for the VA to review.

Submitting Evidence Online vs. Mail

The VA offers an online portal for submitting evidence, which is faster and more secure than mailing physical copies. However, veterans who prefer traditional methods can send their evidence via certified mail to ensure it is received.

Following Up on Your Submission

After submitting evidence, veterans should track the status of their claim through the VA’s online system or by contacting their regional office. Following up ensures all evidence has been received and processed.

Common Challenges in Gathering Evidence and How to Overcome Them

Veterans may encounter obstacles when gathering evidence, but there are solutions to address these challenges.

Dealing with Missing Service Records

If service records are missing, veterans can request a reconstruction or provide alternative evidence, such as buddy statements or unit histories.

Handling Delays in Medical Record Requests

To expedite medical record requests, veterans should follow up regularly with providers and consider using online portals for faster access.

Navigating Complex VA Requirements

Understanding VA documentation standards can be challenging, but veterans can seek assistance from accredited representatives or attorneys to ensure their claim meets all requirements.


For personalized assistance with your VA disability claim, contact Avard Law Offices for a free consultation via the chat on our website or by calling (888) 685-7930. Our Board Certified attorneys are here to help you navigate the process and secure the benefits you deserve.